BlogKlarna vs BigCommerce vs Shopify: 2026 Payment Guide
Table of Contents
Quick Comparison Table
Shopify Payments: Payment Processing and Chargebacks
BigCommerce: Payment Processing and Chargebacks
Klarna: Payment Processing and Chargebacks
When to Use Each (Decision Framework)
How to Reduce Chargebacks Regardless of Platform
Conclusion
14 Aug 2025
8 mins

Klarna vs BigCommerce vs Shopify: 2026 Payment Guide

Share this Article
Klarna vs BigCommerce vs Shopify: 2026 Payment Guide

Last Updated: August 2026

Choosing a payment platform isn't just about the transaction fee on the receipt. It's about chargeback risk, dispute handling, BNPL support, and what the total cost looks like a year from now. This guide compares Klarna, BigCommerce, and Shopify on the dimensions that actually matter to merchants: processing fees, chargeback management, BNPL integration, and payment flexibility.

One thing worth saying upfront: this isn't a "which platform should I build my store on" comparison. Klarna isn't an ecommerce platform at all, it's a payment method. Shopify and BigCommerce are the platforms; Klarna plugs into either one. Keep that distinction in mind as you read, because it changes how you should be comparing these three, and it's a mistake a lot of merchants make when they're shopping around.

Quick Comparison Table

Feature

Shopify (Shopify Payments)

BigCommerce

Klarna

Type

Ecommerce platform + native payments

Ecommerce platform + BigCommerce Payments

BNPL / payment method

Processing Fees

2.9% + 30¢ (Basic) down to 2.25% + 30¢ (Plus)

Processor rate + 0% to 2% Open Payment Provider Fee on non-embedded gateways

Contract-specific; no published public rate

Chargeback Fee

$15 per dispute (US only, varies by country), refunded if you win

Varies by processor

Handled through Klarna's own dispute process

Chargeback Protection

Shopify Protect (eligible Shop Pay orders)

None native

Conditional fraud absorption on approved orders

BNPL Support

Via Shop Pay Installments + third-party apps

Via embedded partners (Klarna, Afterpay, Sezzle)

Native BNPL

Dispute Response Window

7 to 21 days, set by the card network

Varies by processor

7 days (unauthorized), 14 days (other reasons)

Best For

All-in-one simplicity

Payment flexibility, multi-gateway setups

BNPL-first merchants boosting AOV

Shopify's chargeback handling runs through one dashboard no matter which local payment method a customer uses. BigCommerce's runs through whatever processor handled that specific order. Klarna's runs through Klarna, regardless of which platform it's plugged into. Keep that structural difference in mind as you read the fee numbers below, because the number on the receipt only tells half the story.

Shopify Payments: Payment Processing and Chargebacks

Shopify's fee structure runs on plan tier. Basic sits at 2.9% + 30¢ per online transaction, Grow drops to 2.7% + 30¢, Advanced goes to 2.5% + 30¢, and Plus negotiates down to around 2.25% + 30¢ (Shopify Pricing, 2026). Skip Shopify Payments for a third-party gateway and Shopify adds an extra fee that scales by plan too: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced, 0.2% on Plus. That penalty is the whole reason most merchants who start on Shopify end up using Shopify Payments rather than shopping around for a separate processor, the math rarely favors splitting them up unless you're already on Plus with a negotiated rate elsewhere.

Chargebacks work like this: a customer disputes a charge, Shopify pulls the disputed amount plus a chargeback fee from your balance immediately, and you get 7 to 21 days to submit evidence depending on the card network (Shopify Help Center, 2026). That fee is $15 for US merchants specifically; it runs differently in other countries, from £10 in the UK to $25 AUD in Australia. Win the case and the fee comes back, though Shopify's own documentation notes the refund can vary by region, so don't treat it as a guarantee baked into every market.

It's also worth understanding what happens if you lose repeatedly. Shopify tracks your chargeback rate as a percentage of chargeback-eligible transactions, and a high rate can affect your account standing, your eligibility for features like the Shop app, and in worse cases your Shopify Payments account status entirely. This ties directly into the card networks' own monitoring programs, including Visa's Acquirer Monitoring Program, which merchants running high dispute volumes need to stay ahead of regardless of which platform they're on.

Shop Pay orders get an extra layer of coverage called Shopify Protect, reimbursing eligible merchants for fraud-related chargebacks on qualifying orders (Shopify Help Center, 2026). It's not blanket coverage, eligibility depends on the order meeting specific criteria, but it's a real backstop BigCommerce doesn't offer natively. For BNPL, Shop Pay Installments is Shopify's own split-pay option, and merchants can layer Klarna on top through Shopify Payments as a local payment method alongside options like iDEAL and Bancontact, giving international shoppers a checkout experience that matches how they actually pay at home.

Pros: All-in-one setup, Shopify Protect covers some fraud chargebacks, huge app ecosystem, and one dashboard for every dispute regardless of payment method.
Cons: Third-party gateways cost extra, and the chargeback fee hits even when you're likely to win.

BigCommerce: Payment Processing and Chargebacks

BigCommerce doesn't build its own payment processor from scratch, but it does offer BigCommerce Payments, a first-party-branded option powered by PayPal and Braintree. Beyond that, merchants can route through Stripe, Square, and dozens of other gateways, more than 65 in total, which has historically been BigCommerce's biggest selling point against Shopify's more locked-down setup.

That flexibility used to come fee-free across the board. That changed on June 1, 2026. BigCommerce now charges an Open Payment Provider Fee on any transaction processed through a gateway outside its approved Embedded Payment Providers list. The rate depends on plan tier: 2% on Core (formerly Standard), 1% on Growth (formerly Plus), 0.6% on Scale (formerly Pro), and a custom rate on Performance (formerly Enterprise) (BigCommerce, 2026). BigCommerce Payments, Stripe, PayPal, Braintree, Adyen, and Checkout.com are on the approved list, so orders through those stay fee-free. Everything else, including offline and manual payments like purchase orders, is fee-eligible now, which matters more than it sounds like for B2B merchants running a lot of PO-based transactions.

The fee isn't calculated on raw sales. BigCommerce uses what it calls Inclusive GMV, gross order value after a 10% reduction, to determine both plan thresholds and the fee itself (BigCommerce, 2026). That reduction factor changed from 3% to 10% as part of this same update, which means a merchant's Inclusive GMV will look different than it did before, even without any change in actual sales. The plan tiers also got new GMV thresholds alongside the rename: Core caps at $30K trailing-twelve-month GMV, Growth at $100K, and Scale works on a monthly cap of $33,333 with a 0.9% overage rate above that instead of the old fixed per-block charges.

Worth knowing if you're pairing BigCommerce with BNPL: Klarna itself sits on BigCommerce's Embedded Payment Providers list, alongside Afterpay and Sezzle (BigCommerce, 2026). Merchants running Klarna through BigCommerce aren't paying the new fee on those orders, which makes BNPL one of the few payment methods on BigCommerce that dodges the fee entirely without needing to be BigCommerce Payments or Stripe.

Chargeback handling still depends entirely on your chosen processor, since BigCommerce doesn't manage disputes centrally the way Shopify Payments does. If you're running Stripe for cards and PayPal for wallets, you're checking two separate dashboards with two separate response windows and two separate evidence formats. That's the tradeoff for the processor flexibility: more control over rates, less consistency in how disputes get handled.

Pros: No BigCommerce-side fee if you stick to an embedded gateway, flexibility in processor choice, and no penalty for offering multiple payment options at checkout.
Cons: No native chargeback protection, dispute management fragmented across processors, and the new fee has narrowed the "zero transaction fee" gap that used to separate BigCommerce from Shopify.

Klarna: Payment Processing and Chargebacks

Worth repeating: Klarna isn't a platform. It's a BNPL provider that plugs into Shopify, BigCommerce, or dozens of other checkouts. The customer pays Klarna in installments, Klarna pays the merchant upfront, and Klarna carries the credit risk in between. That upfront payment is the core value proposition for merchants, you get paid immediately even though your customer is still paying it off over weeks or months.

Klarna doesn't publish a public merchant rate card. Its own merchant support documentation states pricing varies by market and is set per-contract, with exact rates delivered during onboarding (Klarna US Merchant Support, 2026). Third-party estimates for US merchants cluster in the mid-single-digit percentage range plus a small fixed fee, but treat any specific number you see elsewhere as an estimate, not Klarna's official pricing. If a fee number matters to your decision, get it from your own Klarna contract rather than a blog post, including this one.

Refunds through Klarna have a hard cutoff: 180 days from the initial charge. Past that window, Klarna can't process the refund and you'll need to settle with the customer directly (Shopify Help Center, 2026). That's a long window compared to standard card processing, and it means merchants need a system for tracking which orders are still inside the refund eligibility period, especially for return-heavy categories like apparel.

Disputes run through Klarna's own process, and the deadline depends on why the customer is disputing. Unauthorized purchase claims get a 7-day response window since they're treated as more time-sensitive, while everything else, returns, invoice errors, product not as described, gets 14 days (Klarna Docs, 2026). High-risk orders flagged by Klarna's internal fraud systems move even faster, with just 96 hours to respond since those aren't customer-initiated disputes but Klarna's own early-warning system trying to stop a problem before it becomes one. If a Klarna order escalates into a formal card network dispute rather than staying inside Klarna's own process, Klarna represents the case to the card network directly, using the evidence you submit, with a 7-day deadline for the merchant to provide that evidence (Klarna Merchant Protection Program, 2026).

Pros: Klarna absorbs fraud risk on approved orders where the fraud stems from stolen identity, tends to lift average order value, and resonates with younger shoppers who'd rather split a payment than swipe a card.
Cons: Fees aren't transparent upfront, the refund window is long enough to create bookkeeping headaches, and merchant liability isn't guaranteed if fraud signals were present and unaddressed at checkout, Klarna's protection has real conditions attached, it isn't a blanket guarantee.

When to Use Each (Decision Framework)

Your Situation

Best Choice

Why

Starting a new store, want simplicity

Shopify + Shopify Payments

All-in-one, native chargeback handling

Need maximum payment flexibility

BigCommerce + an embedded gateway

No platform fee if you stay on the approved provider list

Want to offer BNPL to boost AOV

Add Klarna to Shopify or BigCommerce

Klarna absorbs fraud risk on approved BNPL orders

High chargeback risk (subscriptions, digital goods)

Any platform + Chargeblast Deflection

Platform doesn't solve chargeback prevention on its own

Selling internationally

Shopify

Broadest built-in local payment method support

How to Reduce Chargebacks Regardless of Platform

Here's the part none of the above changes: no platform eliminates chargebacks. Whether you're running Shopify Payments, a BigCommerce gateway stack, or Klarna on either one, the fundamentals stay the same:

  • Pre-dispute alerts to intercept disputes before they become formal chargebacks. This is where Chargeblast Deflection sits, working across platforms rather than being tied to one processor, so it doesn't matter whether the dispute originated through Shopify Payments, a BigCommerce gateway, or a Klarna order.
  • Clear billing descriptors so customers recognize the charge on their statement instead of disputing it out of confusion. This sounds basic, but a huge share of "I don't recognize this charge" disputes trace back to a billing name that doesn't match the storefront name customers actually remember shopping at.
  • Delivery confirmation on every shipped order, since it's the single strongest piece of evidence in a "product not received" dispute, and the one most likely to actually win a case regardless of which platform or processor is handling it.
  • A fast, easy refund process. It's almost always cheaper to refund than to fight and lose a chargeback, and a slow refund process is one of the more common reasons customers give up and call their bank instead of waiting.
  • 3DS authentication on higher-risk transactions to shift liability back toward the card issuer, which matters most for merchants selling higher-ticket items where a single fraudulent order does real damage.

For a fuller breakdown of prevention tactics, our chargeback prevention handbook walks through the mechanics in more depth.

Conclusion

Shopify wins on all-in-one simplicity and native chargeback handling. BigCommerce wins on processor flexibility, though the new Open Payment Provider Fee has narrowed that gap since June 2026. Klarna isn't competing with either one, it's a BNPL layer you can add to strengthen conversion on both, with its own separate dispute process to manage regardless of which platform it's sitting on top of.

None of them solve chargebacks on their own. If you want to keep your dispute rate near zero no matter which platform or processor you're running, see how Chargeblast works across Shopify, BigCommerce, and everything in between.

The contents of this article are for general information and education purposes only and should not be construed as legal or tax advice. Chargeblast does not warrant or guarantee the accuracy, completeness, adequacy, or currency of the information in this article.

Share this Article

Reclaim Revenue. Recover Chargebacks
After They've Happened.