Choosing between Stripe vs Shopify Payments can make or break your profit margins. While both platforms advertise similar processing rates, the real costs hide in the fine print. Transaction fees, chargeback penalties, and currency conversion charges add up quickly. Your choice directly impacts how much money stays in your business account each month.
Breaking Down Basic Processing Fees
Shopify Payments starts at 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction for online credit card payments. Stripe matches this rate exactly. But here's where things get interesting. Shopify Payments waives transaction fees for stores using their platform. Stripe charges the same rate regardless of your ecommerce platform.
Physical card readers tell a different story. Shopify's in-person rate drops to 2.7% + 0¢. Stripe's card-present transactions cost 2.7% + 5¢. Those extra nickels multiply fast for brick-and-mortar stores processing hundreds of daily transactions.
International cards trigger higher fees on both platforms. Shopify adds 1% for international payments. Stripe tacks on 1.5% plus another 1% for currency conversion. A $100 sale to a European customer costs $4.90 through Shopify Payments versus $5.40 through Stripe.
The Chargeback Problem Nobody Talks About
Chargebacks hurt twice. First, you lose the sale revenue. Second, both platforms hit you with penalty fees. Shopify charges $15 per chargeback. Stripe charges $15 too, but their dispute resolution tools offer more automation options.
Monthly chargeback rates above 1% trigger additional monitoring fees. Shopify places accounts under review and may increase processing rates by 0.5%. Stripe implements similar measures but provides clearer warning thresholds at 0.75% chargeback ratio.
Fighting chargebacks costs time and money. Shopify's built-in dispute center simplifies evidence submission but lacks advanced fraud detection. Stripe Radar includes machine learning fraud prevention that blocks suspicious transactions before they become chargebacks. The premium version costs $0.02 per transaction but can reduce chargebacks by up to 25%.
Comparing Stripe vs Shopify Payments for Different Business Models
Subscription businesses benefit from Stripe's recurring billing features. Automatic retry logic, dunning management, and prorated upgrades come standard. Shopify Payments requires third-party apps for similar functionality, adding $20-50 monthly to your costs.
Marketplace sellers face platform restrictions. Shopify Payments prohibits split payments to multiple vendors. Stripe Connect handles complex payment flows, though setup requires technical knowledge. The connected account fees add 0.25% plus 25¢ per payout.
High-risk industries encounter approval challenges. CBD products, digital downloads, and dropshipping businesses often get rejected by Shopify Payments. Stripe maintains stricter underwriting but approves more business categories. Their restricted business list clearly outlines acceptable use cases.
Best Shopify Payment Providers Beyond the Big Two
PayPal remains popular despite higher fees. Their standard rate hits 3.49% + 49¢ per transaction. But customer trust and buyer protection programs convert browsers into buyers. Studies show PayPal buttons increase conversion rates by 15-20%.
Authorize.net offers enterprise-level features at competitive rates. Monthly gateway fees start at $25, plus 2.9% + 30¢ per transaction. Advanced fraud detection suites and customizable checkout experiences justify the extra costs for larger merchants.
Square integrates seamlessly with physical retail operations. Their 2.9% + 30¢ online rate matches the competition. Free POS hardware and inventory management tools make them attractive for omnichannel retailers.
Hidden Costs That Affect Your Bottom Line
PCI compliance fees sneak onto monthly statements. Shopify Payments includes PCI compliance in their standard pricing. Stripe charges $10 monthly for non-compliant merchants who don't complete security questionnaires.
Account holds freeze your cash flow. Shopify Payments typically holds funds for 3-5 business days during account reviews. Stripe's rolling reserves can lock up 10% of processing volume for 90 days. New accounts and sudden volume spikes trigger these protective measures.
Early termination fees apply when switching providers. Shopify locks merchants into annual contracts with some payment processors. Breaking these agreements costs $250-500. Stripe operates month-to-month without cancellation penalties.
Making the Numbers Work for Your Business
Calculate your true processing costs using this formula:
A store processing $50,000 monthly with 0.5% chargeback rate pays approximately $1,525 through Shopify Payments. The same volume through Stripe costs $1,537.50 before adding Radar fraud prevention. Small differences compound over time.
Volume discounts kick in differently. Shopify Payments negotiates custom rates above $80,000 monthly processing. Stripe's published rates apply until you hit $1 million annually. Direct negotiations with account managers unlock better pricing tiers.
Conclusion
The battle between Stripe vs Shopify Payments comes down to your specific business needs. Shopify Payments wins for standard ecommerce stores already using Shopify's platform. No transaction fees and integrated checkout create a seamless experience. Stripe excels for complex billing scenarios, international expansion, and businesses requiring advanced developer tools. Calculate your actual costs, including chargebacks, currency fees, and platform limitations. Test both platforms using real transaction data before committing long-term. Your payment processor affects customer experience, cash flow timing, and ultimately your profitability.
FAQ: Stripe VS Shopify Payments
Which is cheaper, Stripe or Shopify Payments?
Shopify Payments costs less for stores exclusively selling through Shopify since they waive transaction fees. Stripe becomes more economical for multi-channel sellers or businesses needing advanced features like subscription billing and marketplace payouts.
Can I use both Stripe and Shopify Payments simultaneously?
You cannot activate both as primary processors on one Shopify store. However, you can use Stripe for external invoicing or other websites while running Shopify Payments on your main store.
How do chargeback fees compare between platforms?
Both charge $15 per disputed transaction regardless of outcome. Stripe's Radar fraud prevention tools help reduce chargebacks before they occur, potentially saving more money despite the additional per-transaction cost.
What happens to my funds if I switch payment processors?
Pending payouts continue processing through your old provider for 30-180 days depending on their policies. New transactions immediately route through your new processor, though initial payouts may face longer hold times.
Do international sellers prefer Stripe or Shopify Payments?
Stripe supports more countries and currencies, making it the default choice for global businesses. Shopify Payments works in fewer regions but offers simpler integration for supported countries.
Take Control of Chargeback Costs with Chargeblast
Losing money to chargebacks affects every payment processor equally. Chargeblast stops disputes before they damage your merchant account. Our prevention system analyzes transaction patterns and blocks fraudulent orders across Stripe, Shopify Payments, and other major processors. Reduce your chargeback rate by up to 99% while keeping legitimate customers happy. Book a demo below and see why thousands of merchants trust us to protect their revenue.
